
Planet Volumes / Unsplash
When Success Splits: Emotional Variance Predicts Higher Ratings but Lower Popularity
Samsun Knight, Matthew Rocklage, Yakov Bart
Working Paper
|
September 2, 2026
Products people praise should be products people choose. Yet ratings and popularity can disagree. What predicts when they do? We propose that one answer lies in a cultural product's emotional variance-the degree to which distinct emotions (e.g., joy, fear, sadness) fluctuate over its duration. A multimethod investigation combines computational linguistics, machine learning, and experiments. We validate and apply a linguistic emotion classifier to more than 50,000 cultural products-over 3,000 movies, 12,000 TV episodes, and 36,000 songs. We find that products with greater emotional variance consistently receive higher ratings but are less popular, even after accounting for a broad set of alternative explanations. Two controlled experiments then manipulate emotional variance in written narratives. Before consumption, emotionally variable content seems more challenging to consume, discouraging consumption. During consumption, the same content is more engaging, leading to higher ratings. Together, the findings identify a predictable source of divergence between ratings and popularity and show how a single product feature can pull two common measures of success in opposite directions.
citation
Knight, S., Rocklage, M., & Bart, Y. (2026). When Success Splits: Emotional Variance Predicts Higher Ratings but Lower Popularity [Preprint]. SSRN. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.7383138
topics
Marketing & Advertising
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence
related work

Measuring Agency-Amplifying AI Literacy: The HuskyAI Coaching Platform for Workforce Readiness
July 2026
HuskyAI is a web platform on which students develop AI knowledge by working through authentic
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence
Working Paper


Measuring Agency-Amplifying AI Literacy: The HuskyAI Coaching Platform for Workforce Readiness
July 2026
HuskyAI is a web platform on which students develop AI knowledge by working through authentic
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence
Working Paper


Measuring Agency-Amplifying AI Literacy: The HuskyAI Coaching Platform for Workforce Readiness
July 2026
HuskyAI is a web platform on which students develop AI knowledge by working through authentic
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence
Working Paper

.png)