
Function over Fidelity: Coral Reefs and The Future of Conservation Law
Alejandro E. Camacho, Elias van Emmerick, Ronald Sandler, Mikhail Matz, Andrew C. Baker
Working Paper
|
September 22, 2026
Coral reefs are among the first ecosystems to cross a major climate-induced threshold soon to be imposed on many more habitats—when ecological function cannot be maintained by remaining fully faithful to recent historical state. In Florida, two of the keystone species—elkhorn and staghorn coral—that built shallow reef structures are now functionally extinct in the wild, and restoration of reefs to historical baselines is no longer feasible. Yet the international, federal, and state laws that govern coral conservation embed a powerful preference for historical fidelity and native composition, discouraging or prohibiting forward-looking interventions—from assisted gene flow to the introduction of non-native ecological replacements—that have better chances of preserving the reef’s ecological function. Using Florida’s Coral Reef as a frontline case study, this Article argues that unconditional fidelity to historical and “natural” baselines is no longer a defensible default for conservation law. It surveys the full spectrum of possible interventions and the scientific, legal, and ethical tradeoffs each entails, and it contends that the law should move from categorical native/non-native prohibitions toward a structured, risk-assessment-based framework—one that authorizes interventions in reversible stages, invites meaningful public and cross-jurisdictional participation, and adapts as it learns. Coral reefs are the leading case, but the problem, and the framework we propose, extends across conservation law.
citation
Camacho, A. E., van Emmerick, E., Sandler, R., Matz, M., & Baker, A. C. (2026). Function over Fidelity: Coral Reefs and The Future of Conservation Law [Preprint]. SSRN. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.7500138
topics
Policy & Governance
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence
related work

Measuring Agency-Amplifying AI Literacy: The HuskyAI Coaching Platform for Workforce Readiness
July 2026
HuskyAI is a web platform on which students develop AI knowledge by working through authentic
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence
Working Paper


Measuring Agency-Amplifying AI Literacy: The HuskyAI Coaching Platform for Workforce Readiness
July 2026
HuskyAI is a web platform on which students develop AI knowledge by working through authentic
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence
Working Paper


Measuring Agency-Amplifying AI Literacy: The HuskyAI Coaching Platform for Workforce Readiness
July 2026
HuskyAI is a web platform on which students develop AI knowledge by working through authentic
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence
Working Paper

.png)